[Gomer] I looked away, one, two, three, four, five, many times Guess you could say I'm to blame But didn't I say a harlot's not much of a bride? I ran away, who's to say this one's different? And differently I, I made a statement By making these strangers and sinners mine for the night The tears stayed in my eyes As you took me in your arms and carried me inside You dressed the wounds I gave myself You held the mess I made myself Bathed me, laid me down for the night And when you thought me sound asleep You went outside and cried Oh, Hosea You are too kind I made a mess of everything When I should've made you mine Oh, Hosea Beloved, is it hopeless? I tried to make you understand That I was damned But now we're both just broken The next morning I find you singing over me And you bring me to the vineyard like a bride and not a sinner And then your lips shape a smile That fills your eyes with poetry [Hosea] I know that we aren't perfect, but what if we were worth it? [Gomer] You say, but I look away Oh, how many times I've heard this But I'm nothing like this church kid Who loves me like I've earned it Who loves to hand his heart out to the ones who tried to burn it The tears stayed in my eyes As the fire in his threatened to die He said goodnight and went inside I curse the rooms I gave to him I hate the mess I made of him Wait till he laid down for the night And when I found him sound asleep I watched him breathing quietly and cried Oh, Hosea You are too kind I made a mess of everything When I should've made you mine Oh, Hosea Beloved, is it hopeless? I tried to make you understand That I was damned But now we're both just broken Did I wake him with my weeping? Was he never really sleeping? He sits up and tenderly says [Hosea] Come lay down with me [Gomer] I lay next to him And start to cry again He holds me tighter, then says [Hosea] We can try again [Gomer] And I cling to him And I cling to him And he says [Hosea] Mrs. Hosea You are my bride I wanna give you everything But for now I'll give you time Mrs. Hosea Beloved, it's not hopeless So long as you understand That my ring there on your hand means we're one [Hosea and Gomer] Even when we're broken