Annie can't sleep in the middle of the night She wanders outside in the cool moonlight Stares at the heavens above, sayin' Where is love? Billy's out late, he's cruisin' in his car He downs a couple drinks at the local bar Still he can't believe she's gone Where did they go wrong? It always feels like love is such a sure thing Till you can't stop it slippin' away And when it feels like fate is out of your hands All that you can do is pray So, baby, make a wish with your magic wand To a lucky star that silently you're dreamin' on She thinks about the past from beginning to end And how different it would be if they could do it again 'Cause they're so much wiser now Than they were back then But it ain't that often you get another chance Second time around with your first romance A little bit of magic, that's all That's all they need right now It always feels like love is such a sure thing Till you've made almost every mistake And when it feels like fate is out of your hands Hold on, 'cause it's never too late Make a wish with your magic wand To a lucky star that silently you're dreamin' on And burn a candle in the night The flame is love, and hope is light And make a wish that everything will turn out right, oh Baby, make a wish with your magic wand To a lucky star that silently you're dreamin' on And burn a candle in the night The flame is love, and hope is light And make a wish that everything will turn out right Baby, make a wish Baby, make a wish Baby, make a wish Ooh, make a wish