Maybe we were too good We were too good to be Boy you should be scared of me First thing that you said to me But I laughed it off Yeah, I laughed it off You were always teasin' me And I would you call my dummy But who woulda thought That I wanted more And I know it sounds cliché But this is different babe I swear I swear Buy you two diamond rings 'Cause one ain't 'nough to show you what you mean To me 'Cause if it isn't you Then, who else could it possibly be? And if this isn't true Love is nothing more than a cheat What am I to do If God didn't make me for you What I gotta prove To show you that I'm not something you wanna lose Maybe we were too good We were too good to be true Fallen unexpectedly But you were too good on your feet Oh, I shoulda known When you hung up the phone You were losing energy And I was sinking in too deep Baby, tell me now Did we fall apart? And I know it sounds cliche But this is different babe I swear I swear Buy you two diamond rings 'Cause one ain't -nough to show you what you mean To me 'Cause if it isn't you Then who else could it possibly be? And if this isn't true Love is nothing more than a cheat What am I to do If God didn't make me for you What I gotta prove To show you that I'm not something you wanna lose Maybe we were too good We were too good to be true Who's to say we're too good Say we're too good To be true