I've been avoiding mirrors And my reflection in the glass 'Cause it hurts to see the man that I am now That I am now I never should've let you go Now I know That it should've been us Or maybe it wasn't meant to be I live with your shadow now Burnt into my memory Sometimes you don't get it right the first time So close but out of reach It should've been us (should've been us) But it all turned out to be Nevergreen Been cutting corners And wondering what you're up to Is this a daydream or not? Where will I find you? Is it just me or is it we? Call it wishful thinking Staring at the ceiling Never should've walkеd away (walked away) Can you hear me say That it should'vе been us? Or maybe it wasn't meant to be I live with your shadow now Burnt into my memory Sometimes you don't get it right the first time So close but out of reach It should've been us (should've been us) But it all turned out to be Nevergreen Where are you now? (where are you now?) Just a little out of reach Is it me or is it we? Call it wishful thinking Where are you now? (where are you now?) Is it something I can't see? I never should've walked away Am I too late? 'Cause it shoulda been us I know your love is what I need So if I ever cross your mind Then you know where to find me It should've been us (should've been us) Or maybe it wasn't meant to be I live with your shadow now (shadow now) Burnt into my memory Sometimes you don't get it right the first time So close but out of reach It should've been us (should've been us) But it all turned out to be Nevergreen