Dm            C                         Bb
  Last time, I thought we had this talk
     Gm
Boy, you were getting ready to leave
Dm               C                  Bb
  I thought that baby you were done
                              Gm
Cause for a while, you could barely look at me
Dm               C                        Bb
  This time, I thought that we'd be fine
     Gm
That I'd forget the thing that you said
Dm          C                     Bb
  I tried crossing out your words
                  Gm
But baby, you can not forget the past
Dm C Bb  Gm
      Can not forget the past
Dm C Bb         Gm
    Still, baby

[Chorus]
            Dm                      Bb
I'm so unpredictable, you don't know what to think
       F                      C
So unemotional, wonder if I'm even still in love
       Dm               Bb
You see, I don't know what to tell you now
     F               C
It's always harder the second time around
          Dm               Bb
I'm so unbreakable, just like you used to be
      F                   C
So unemotional, boy - I can't forget the way you were with me
Dm               Bb
I don't know what to tell you know
     F             C
It's always harder the second time around

[Instrumental]
Dm C Bb Gm (2x)

[Verse 2]
Dm            C                         Bb
  We tried going back to Joe's
      Gm
That always was our favorite place
Dm            C                         Bb
  Long rides, baby - by the coast
          Gm
Do you remember where we stayed?
Dm            C                         Bb
  Last time, we were hanging out
       Gm
You were acting kind of strange
Dm            C                         Bb
  Now it's the second time around
                  Gm
I'm sorry, now it's me that feels this way
Dm  C  Bb   Gm
      (My heart just takes its turn)
                 It's me that feels this way
Dm  C  Bb                         Gm
          I know that you are the one that is hurt...

[Chorus]
 Dm                      Bb
I'm so unpredictable, you don't know what to think
       F                      C
So unemotional, wonder if I'm even still in love
       Dm               Bb
You see, I don't know what to tell you now
     F               C
It's always harder the second time around
          Dm               Bb
I'm so unbreakable, just like you used to be
      F                   C
So unemotional, boy - I can't forget the way you were with me
Dm               Bb
I don't know what to tell you know
     F             C
It's always harder the second time around

[Bridge]
Bb                        Dm
    I'm not sure the best way to say this
            G#                       Eb
But I can't pretend to love you no more, babe
Ebm                              Bb
    This Ferris wheel's got me crazy
  C                              Am
Maybe the second time around is not meant for us, baby
Dm C Bb Gm
      Not meant for us, baby
Dm C Bb Gm

[Outro]
 Dm                 Bb
I'm so unpredictable, you don't know what to think
       F                C
So unemotional, wonder if I'm even still in love
         Dm               Bb
You see, I don't know what to tell you now
     F               C
It's always harder the second time around
          Dm               Bb
I'm so unbreakable, just like you used to be
      F                   C
So unemotional, boy - I can't forget the way you were with me
Dm               Bb
I don't know what to tell you know
     F             C
It's always harder the second time around (x4)