A small-town no one, a young love-a-holic
A late-night drunk text left unacknowledged
A number I saved knowing I'll never call it
A just this once if you want it

But that was the old me
Baby, I'm so glad you didn't know me
Innocent enough, oh I was lonely
But I don't feel the same with you

Slicked-back hair and the skinny jeans
The type I tell you that I love you then get up and leave
And I was in and I was out and never in between, oh, oh
And then you crash right in through an open door
And suddenly I'm having feelings that I didn't before
And no, I didn't see it coming, but I know where it's going, oh

You said, burn your clothes
Thanks for the note
Politely hated everything I own
(So) out of my league
(Yes) pretty please
I'll be whoever you want me to be

But the old me
Baby, I'm so glad you didn't know me
Innocent enough, oh I was lonely
But I don't feel the same with you

Slicked-back hair and the skinny jeans
The type I tell you that I love you then get up and leave
And I was in and I was out and never in between, oh, oh
And then you crash right in through an open door
And suddenly I'm having feelings that I didn't before
And no, I didn't see it coming, but I know where it's going, oh

Only God can judge me
Comically unlucky
You just seem so lovely
Can I stay with you?

Only God can judge me
Comically unlucky
You just seem so lovely
Can I stay with you?

Slicked-back hair and the skinny jeans
The type I tell you I love you then get up and leave
And I was in and I was out and never in between, oh, oh
And then you crash right in through an open door
And suddenly I'm having feelings that I didn't before
And no, I didn't see it coming, but I know where it's going
Oh