I spend this evening with this girl I've been seeing since you left
She wanted to meet in the same restaurant that we did
As she kissed me while I got the bill
Every butterfly in me was still
Oh, I'm with her, but I'm in love with you

After we walked and she started to talk about romance
With my eyes at my feet and the cracks in the street, we held hands
I couldn't hold her as long because
It didn't fit mine like yours
Oh, I'm with her, but I'm in love with you

Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, I'm with her, but I'm in love with you

In the taxi, she shimmied right across the backseat next to me
The driver said we were the cutest couple that he'd seen
I smiled so she could see, but my heart would never agree
Oh, I'm with her, but I'm in love with you

The man at the wheel said: I know you, I play all your songs
Then she started to sing with him the one I wrote about you
She sat on my knee, and she asked: Is this one about me? While she laughed
Oh, I'm with her, but I'm in love with you

Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, I'm with her, but I'm in love with you
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, I'm with her, but I'm in love with you

I'm with her, but I'm in love with you